Homework Guy Car Buying Service: The Truth vs Reddit
One misleading Reddit post claims “I regret using The Homework Guy car buying service” — but here’s the truth behind that experience, the facts it leaves out, and why so many of our clients keep giving us 5-star reviews.
When One Person Misleads… We have to Set the Record Straight.
We recently became aware of a Reddit post titled, “I regret using The Homework Guy car buying service.” While we welcome feedback — even criticism — what we don’t accept is misleading claims that distort the truth and leave out crucial context.
If you’re considering using our car buying service, you deserve to hear the full story — not just one user’s skewed experience.
What Really Happened
The Reddit post in question was made by someone who worked with our coach, Jeremy, to purchase a Toyota RAV4 — a vehicle that has consistently ranked as one of the highest-demand cars in the U.S. in recent years. It’s a great car — and yes, that also makes it harder to negotiate steep discounts.
More about the Toyota RAV4 and why it is so popular
Despite this, our coach helped the client:
✅ Secure the exact vehicle they wanted
✅ Avoid $3,000–$3,500 in forced add-ons typically applied at the dealership (window etching, paint protection, etc.)
✅ Get out-the-door pricing clarity, so there were no last-minute surprises
✅ All for just $1,000 total cost of service with us
That’s a net gain of thousands of dollars in savings and protection from dealership tactics — a result we’re proud of.
Unrealistic Expectations? Maybe. But That’s Not Regret.
In our experience, some clients come in believing we can shave $5,000 off a vehicle in peak demand. And while we often negotiate great deals, the laws of supply and demand still apply.
When a vehicle is flying off the lot, even manufacturers don’t offer rebates. Dealers don’t have to beg people to buy it. That doesn’t mean we failed — it means we helped you avoid being ripped off in a market where many others are overpaying.
We Even Offered a Refund. No Response.
When our founder Kevin Hunter heard about the client’s disappointment, he reached out personally and offered a refund — no games, no arguing.
We never heard back.
We stand behind our service — and we’re willing to go the extra mile to fix it when someone feels they didn’t get full value. But silence speaks volumes.
Meanwhile… 4.9 Stars on Google and Growing Daily
We’ve helped thousands of buyers across the U.S. navigate shady dealer tactics, uncover hidden fees, and get the car they want without getting scammed.
Our Google rating is 4.9 stars with hundreds of verified reviews.
Here’s what real clients are saying:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “They helped me save $2,800 on junk fees the dealer insisted were ‘mandatory.’ Worth every penny.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “I was skeptical, but this was the smoothest car deal I’ve ever done. Transparent, honest, and fast.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Jeremy is a rockstar. He negotiated everything. I just signed and drove off.”
Read our Google Reviews here: https://maps.app.goo.gl/yXfP4JUvbMQpZaES6
In Closing: You Can Trust The Homework Guy
We’re not a magic wand. We can’t rewrite market conditions or make dealers beg for a deal. But what we can do — and have done for thousands of people — is bring honesty, protection, and leverage back to your car buying experience. In that effort, we are succeeding every day.
We hope the individual who posted on Reddit finds what they’re looking for. But to anyone reading that post, ask yourself:
- Would you rather trust one anonymous comment…
- …or hundreds of verified clients with real receipts and real savings? Our positive Google reviews are not a fluke. But one unhappy customer is proof that we can’t make everyone happy no matter how hard we try.
The choice is yours. And if you’re ready to buy smart, avoid scams, and get the truth, we’re still here — fighting for car buyers like you every day.
👇 Ready to learn more or speak with a coach?
Visit thehomeworkguy.com , click on the pull down menu and select “Hassle free car buying service.” You can also check out our real reviews on [Google].